Yue, I was very interested in your analysis of Newcastle as a city through Lynch’s five elements and I agree that people experience a city through sight, sound etc. and deepen their impressions of a city. I have to admit that Newcastle does combine the richness of the city with the tranquillity of the landscape and the very wide range of transport options. You have also highlighted in your blog the impact of paths on the image of the city, and I agree. I would also like to highlight the impact of landmarks on the image of a city. it is seen as a valid approach to promote cities is the construction of landmark architecture (M.Riza, 2012)It is clear that if there is a world renowned iconic building in a city, it will attract more investors and tourists to come, which benefits the economic growth. In other words, attracting more investors and tourists from other cities through landmark buildings to increase the the flow of people in the city, drive the consumption of the city and establish the image of the city. On the other hand, a special kind of design problem is giving image to the city in order to make the image of the city more vivid and memorable (K.Lynch, 1960). It means that attracting people to the city is the first step so that they can feel the other good things in the city.
M.Riza, N.Doratli, M.Fasli (2012) City branding and identity Procedia-soc.Behav.sci, pp.293-300.
K.Lynch (1960) The Image of the City, Massachusetts Institute of Technology Cambridge, Massachusetts, and London, England.
Yue, I was very interested in your analysis of Newcastle as a city through Lynch’s five elements and I agree that people experience a city through sight, sound etc. and deepen their impressions of a city. I have to admit that Newcastle does combine the richness of the city with the tranquillity of the landscape and the very wide range of transport options. You have also highlighted in your blog the impact of paths on the image of the city, and I agree. I would also like to highlight the impact of landmarks on the image of a city. it is seen as a valid approach to promote cities is the construction of landmark architecture (M.Riza, 2012)It is clear that if there is a world renowned iconic building in a city, it will attract more investors and tourists to come, which benefits the economic growth. In other words, attracting more investors and tourists from other cities through landmark buildings to increase the the flow of people in the city, drive the consumption of the city and establish the image of the city. On the other hand, a special kind of design problem is giving image to the city in order to make the image of the city more vivid and memorable (K.Lynch, 1960). It means that attracting people to the city is the first step so that they can feel the other good things in the city.
M.Riza, N.Doratli, M.Fasli (2012) City branding and identity Procedia-soc.Behav.sci, pp.293-300.
K.Lynch (1960) The Image of the City, Massachusetts Institute of Technology Cambridge, Massachusetts, and London, England.
Yue, i agree with your perception about Newcastle being different from big cities like London. It is a serene, comfortable contrast to the vast and huge endless concrete jungle. I like your description of Lynch’s design elements through personalised Newcastle’s example in it. The legibility of any city is indeed identified by these basic elements but there are a lot of other dimensions to a city.
There are six types of dimensions of urban design. They are: the Morphological dimension – Urban Morphology, Landuses, Street patterns; the Perceptual dimension- environmental perception(the five senses); the Social dimension – activities, public realm, neighbourhoods, safety and security ; the Visual dimension- patterns, aesthetics, positive and negative spaces; the Functional dimension- public/ private/social spaces; and the temporal dimension- the factor that changes with time.
lttelson identifies four dimensions of perception, which operate simultaneously:
COGNITIVE: involves thinking about, organising and keeping information. In essence, it enables us to make sense of the environment.
AFFECTIVE: involves our feelings, which influence perception of the environment – equally, perception of the environment influences our feelings.
INTERPRETATIVE: encompasses meaning derived from the environment. In interpreting information, we rely on memory for points of comparison with newly experienced stimuli.
EVALUATIVE: incorporates values and preferences and the determination of ‘good’ or ‘bad’
References:
Matthew Caroma, Public Places Urban Spaces: The Dimensions of Urban Design (3rd Edition) https://matthew-carmona.com/books/
William. H. Ittelson, Visual perception of markings (1996) http://nschwartz.yourweb.csuchico.edu/Ittelson,%201996%20Visual%20perception%20of%20world%20vs%20pictures.pdf
William. H. Ittelson, The constancies in perceptual theory (1951)
https://psycnet.apa.org/record/1952-03186-001
Ceiliy, this blog has a great foundation for human spaitial perception on Newcastle as a City. And I agree with you that Newcastle is a vibrant city with tranquil landscape. Furthermore, each city has their own distinctive characteristics which make each one unique. However, even if city have the same buildings and layout, climate elements also chance the sensory perception (Gibson, 1966).
The opposite of intimacy is the perception of safety. As urban designers, we also need to consider the feelings of safety in urban environment, this is additional to Lynch 5 physical elements (Lynch, 2014). Therefore, physical characteristic should be the forefront, and designing social and safe environments should be on same level to stimulation and social interactions.
Lastly, a landmark can be in a psychological map, that something more abstract that a monument or significant building. In which, you did identify café (of smell). Moreover, soundscape, smell, chatty maps are also important for people to create mental maps of a happy city (Quercia et al, 2017).
Reference:
Gibson, J. (1966) The senses considered as perceptual systems. Oxford, England: Houghton Miffin.
Lynch, K. (2014) Image of the City. Boston: Birkhauser.
Quercia, D., Aiello, L. & Schifanella, R. (2017) ‘Mapping towards a Good City Life’, Journal of Urban Design Mental Health. Volume 3, Issues 3.